Insurance Fraud in Ireland: Aviva Calls for Central Fraud Hub

Aviva urges greater industry-wide collaboration to combat organised fraud, AI-generated scams and evolving insurance crime threats in Ireland.

Aviva Insurance Ireland DAC (Aviva) Calls for Central Insurance Industry Fraud Hub as Fraud Becomes More Sophisticated

  • Over the past five years*, Aviva has reported more than 500 suspected fraudsters to An Garda Síochána
  • Aviva also challenged 600 litigated suspected fraudulent claims, with almost half (47%) either withdrawn before reaching court or successfully defended by Aviva
  • Aviva is warning that insurance fraud is becoming more sophisticated, with criminals using fake documents, online channels and AI-generated images to deceive customers
  • Investigations into organised insurance fraud can take several years, with the current capacity for information sharing across the industry making it harder to detect patterns and links between cases
  • Aviva is calling for a Central Insurance Industry Fraud Hub to help insurers share intelligence, identify fraud trends earlier and strengthen efforts to tackle insurance fraud
  • A similar industry wide fraud hub has operated in the UK since 2006, with the Insurance Fraud Bureau (IFB)’s investigations helping to secure more than 1,300 arrests and over 690 convictions**

Aviva Insurance Ireland DAC (Aviva) is calling for the establishment of a Central Insurance Industry Fraud Hub as fraud becomes more sophisticated and newer fraud trends continue to emerge.

The hub would provide a single place for insurers to share information on suspected fraud and emerging scam trends, helping to identify patterns earlier, strengthen investigations and protect consumers.

Aviva believes greater industry-wide information sharing would be particularly valuable in tackling organised fraud, where links between people, claims or suspected fraud may not be visible to one insurer alone.

Insurers are seeing a growing range of fraud risks, including ghost broking, organised claims fraud, online scams and the use of AI to manipulate documents and images. Aviva believes the hub would help the industry identify emerging trends earlier and respond more effectively to increasingly sophisticated scams.

Aviva takes a zero-tolerance approach to insurance fraud. Over the past five years, Aviva has reported more than 500 suspected fraudsters to An Garda Síochána. Aviva also challenged 600 litigated suspected fraudulent claims, with almost half (47%) withdrawn or successfully defended before reaching court.

Insurance fraud investigations can be complex and can take several years to conclude

Investigating organised insurance fraud can be a lengthy and complex process, often requiring significant expertise, resources and collaboration across multiple parties.  

In one recent organised fraud investigation, suspicious claims remained under investigation for more than a decade before proceedings were concluded.

Investigators also continue to encounter cases where information in support of claims is not found to be accurate following further investigation, highlighting the importance of robust fraud detection and evidence gathering.

Together, these cases demonstrate the breadth of insurance fraud and the extensive work often required to investigate suspicious activity and protect honest consumers.

Insurance Ireland has previously estimated that claims fraud costs the industry more than €200 million annually***.

New fraud threats emerging

Alongside traditional fraud, insurers are increasingly dealing with scams facilitated through digital channels.

Recent research**** found that more than 90% of senior compliance experts believe AI is now being used to commit financial fraud, while the Central Bank of Ireland has also warned consumers about unauthorised firms using details copied from legitimate insurance businesses to advertise car insurance*****.

Ghost broking remains a concern across the industry, with fraudsters using social media and messaging platforms to sell fake or manipulated insurance policies. Recent investigations have uncovered forged insurance documentation designed to make fraudulent policies appear legitimate to consumers. Organised fraudsters are increasingly using encrypted messaging apps, cryptocurrency, QR code payments and disappearing message settings on smartphones to hide their activities and avoid detection by law enforcement.

Across the business, Aviva is seeing evidence of increasingly sophisticated fraud techniques, including manipulated documents and AI-generated imagery designed to support false or exaggerated claims.

As these technologies become more accessible, fraudulent activity can become more difficult to detect. In response, Aviva continues to invest in specialist expertise, data analytics and technology to help identify and prevent fraud.

Better information sharing

Aviva believes a Central Insurance Industry Fraud Hub would allow insurers to share information on suspected fraud and emerging fraud trends more effectively.

The UK has had a similar system in place for 20 years. Its Insurance Fraud Bureau (IFB) brings together information from insurers to help identify links and organised fraud. The IFB databases hold information on more than 250,000 people, businesses and other parties linked to suspected fraud and details of over 21,000 confirmed fraudsters, with members carrying out nearly 200,000 searches each year*****.

Since it was established, IFB investigations have also helped to secure more than 1,300 arrests and over 690 convictions, totalling more than 620 years in prison.

Bringing this information together can help uncover links and wider fraud patterns that one insurer may not be able to see on its own.

Aviva believes a similar approach in Ireland could help insurers identify emerging fraud trends earlier, strengthen investigations and support a more coordinated response to increasingly sophisticated fraud.

Insurance fraud is not a victimless crime. It increases costs across the insurance system and ultimately impacts honest customers. We've reported more than 500 suspected fraudsters to An Garda Síochána over the past 5 years and continue to see insurance fraud evolve in new ways. We're seeing increasingly sophisticated scams, including the use of AI to manipulate documents and images in support of fraudulent claims. Some fraud investigations can take years to resolve and require significant expertise, time and resources. A Central Insurance Industry Fraud Hub would help the industry respond more effectively to emerging fraud trends and protect customers from evolving fraud risks

Rob Smyth, Head of Investigations and Fraud at Aviva Insurance Ireland DAC, said

How consumers can protect themselves

Aviva encourages consumers to:

  • Check that an insurance provider, broker or intermediary is authorised by using the Central Bank of Ireland’s Register of Authorised Firms
  • Be cautious of insurance products sold through social media or messaging platforms
  • Be wary of requests to transfer funds to personal bank accounts
  • Carefully review policy documents before making payments
  • Be cautious of policy documents or certificates that appear unusual and contact the insurer directly to confirm they are genuine
  • Question deals that appear significantly cheaper than alternatives
  • Contact an insurer, broker or financial advisor directly if they have concerns about the legitimacy of a policy or provider

For more information, visit aviva.ie.

ENDS


*refers to Aviva Insurance Ireland DAC (Aviva) data from July 2021 to June 2026

**as reported by PEIA

***according to Insurance Ireland

****according to the Compliance Institute in 2026

*****according to TheJournal

******according to the Insurance Fraud Bureau

Media Centre

Visit our Media Centre page to find our latest new releases and media contacts details.

Media contacts

Brian O'Neill - Head of Communications

086 6069702

Saoirse Whelan – Communications and PR Manager

087 4024667